Caroline Pitofsky

Caroline Pitofsky, yeah, she's probably not a household name—yet. But if you dig a little deeper, you’ll spot her name tucked into the credits of some pretty wild projects. Take Fear Street: Prom Queen (2025). This one? Not your average high school horror flick. Think classic slasher vibes with a juicy twist: prom night, glitter, drama, and something nasty lurking behind the gym doors. Pitofsky knows how to dial up the tension without making it feel like a cheap jump scare fest. Characters actually feel like real teenagers, not just horror-movie clichés. The way she paces the chaos—one minute everyone’s slow dancing, the next, boom, chaos—honestly, it’s impressive. There’s a weird nostalgia to it, too, like she snuck in little moments that remind you of your own cringey prom pics, just before someone starts running for their life. Then there’s No Garlic (2017). Totally different universe. Gone are the bloodstains and teen drama—now it’s indie, quirky, and weirdly charming. You know those offbeat comedies that don’t try too hard? That’s the vibe. Pitofsky plays with awkward silences and oddball characters, finding heart in the strangest places. The humor sneaks up on you. She’s not afraid to get a little weird, and honestly, it pays off. Both films prove she’s got range—one foot in horror, one in indie comedy, and somehow she makes both work. Not bad for someone flying under the mainstream radar.